Steel Manning Arguments

What is Steel Manning?

Steel manning is the practice of presenting the strongest possible version of someone's argument before critiquing it. Instead of attacking a weak or distorted version of their position (straw manning), you strengthen their argument by adding the best evidence, reasoning, and context you can think of.

This approach works by:

Building up: Making the opposing argument as strong as possible
Understanding deeply: Really grasping what the other person means
Arguing fairly: Addressing their best points, not their worst
Finding truth: Discovering what's valid in opposing viewpoints

Straw Man vs. Steel Man Comparison

🥖 Straw Manning (Weak)

Makes arguments easier to attack

Distorts the opposing position
Focuses on weak points
Misrepresents their reasoning
Creates artificial wins
Prevents real understanding

🛡️ Steel Manning (Strong)

Makes arguments stronger to truly test them

Strengthens the opposing position
Focuses on their best points
Adds supporting evidence
Challenges your own thinking
Builds genuine understanding

How to Steel Man an Argument

👂

1. Listen Carefully

Pay close attention to what the person is actually saying. Ask clarifying questions if needed.

Instead of assuming: "Can you help me understand what you mean by..."

🔍

2. Find Their Best Evidence

Look for the strongest evidence and reasoning that supports their position, even if they didn't present it well.

Ask yourself: "What's the best case someone could make for this position?"

🏗️

3. Strengthen Their Reasoning

Add logical connections, context, and supporting arguments that make their case more compelling.

Think: "How could this argument be made more persuasive and complete?"

🔄

4. State It Back

Present the strengthened version back to them for confirmation before proceeding with your response.

Say: "Let me make sure I understand your position correctly..."

💭

5. Then Respond

Only after you've steel manned their position should you present your counterarguments.

Approach: Address their strongest points, not their weakest ones.

Detailed Example: Remote Work Debate

The Original Disagreement

Context: A company meeting about remote work policies.

Jessica (Manager)

"I think we should require everyone to be in the office. People just don't work as hard from home, and we lose that team energy."

Mike (Employee) - Straw Manning

"So you think we're all lazy slackers who can't be trusted to do our jobs? That's insulting and shows you don't understand modern work at all."

Sarah (Employee) - Steel Manning

"Let me make sure I understand your concerns. You're worried that remote work might reduce productivity because some tasks benefit from real-time collaboration, and you value the creative energy and spontaneous idea-sharing that happens when teams work together in person. You've probably seen research showing that some types of innovation happen more easily with face-to-face interaction. Is that right?"

Jessica

"Yes, exactly! Thank you for understanding my perspective."

Sarah - Thoughtful Response

"Those are valid concerns. I think the key is finding the right balance. Could we consider a hybrid model where we have dedicated in-office days for collaborative work and brainstorming, while allowing focused work to happen remotely?"

Analysis of the Difference

❌

Mike's Straw Man Approach

Distorted Jessica's concerns into personal attacks, created defensiveness, and shut down productive discussion.

✅

Sarah's Steel Man Approach

Acknowledged valid concerns, added supporting context, and opened the door for collaborative problem-solving.

Benefits of Steel Manning

🧠 Better Understanding

Forces you to truly understand opposing viewpoints rather than dismissing them. You might discover valid points you hadn't considered.

💪 Stronger Arguments

Your own arguments become stronger because you've tested them against the best version of opposing views, not weak caricatures.

🤝 Better Relationships

People feel heard and respected when you engage with their actual positions. This builds trust and reduces defensiveness.

🎯 Finding Common Ground

By understanding the best parts of opposing arguments, you're more likely to find areas of agreement and build collaborative solutions.

📚 Personal Growth

Challenges your own biases and assumptions. You might change your mind or refine your position based on new insights.

🏆 Intellectual Honesty

Demonstrates good faith engagement and intellectual integrity. Shows you're interested in truth, not just winning arguments.

When to Use Steel Manning

🗣️ Workplace Disagreements

Situation: Colleagues disagree on project approaches
Steel Man: Present the strongest case for each approach before evaluating pros and cons.

👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Family Discussions

Situation: Disagreement about household rules or decisions
Steel Man: Acknowledge the valid concerns behind different family members' positions.

💼 Business Strategy

Situation: Team debating different strategic directions
Steel Man: Present the best case for each strategy before making decisions.

🗳️ Political Discussions

Situation: Disagreement about policies or candidates
Steel Man: Present the strongest arguments for positions you disagree with.

Advanced Steel Manning Techniques

🔍

Research Their Position

Go beyond what they've said and research the best academic or expert arguments for their position.

Example: If someone argues against a policy, look up the strongest research-based arguments against it.

🎭

Play Devil's Advocate for Yourself

Steel man arguments against your own position to test your thinking and find weak spots.

Ask: "What's the strongest case someone could make against my position?"

🌍

Consider Different Contexts

Think about situations where their argument would be particularly strong or compelling.

Think: "In what circumstances would this position make the most sense?"

⏰

Consider Historical Context

Look at how their position has been supported historically or in different cultures.

Explore: "How has this viewpoint been valuable in different times or places?"

Challenges and How to Overcome Them

😤 Emotional Reactions

Challenge: Hard to steel man positions that trigger strong emotions.
Solution: Take time to cool down before engaging. Focus on understanding, not agreeing.

⏰ Time Investment

Challenge: Steel manning takes more time and effort than straw manning.
Solution: Remember that better understanding leads to more productive conversations and better outcomes.

🤔 Confusion with Agreement

Challenge: People might think steel manning means you agree with the position.
Solution: Clarify that you're presenting their best argument to engage with it fairly, not because you agree.

🎯 Finding the Real Argument

Challenge: Sometimes people present their arguments poorly or unclearly.
Solution: Ask questions to clarify their position before attempting to strengthen it.

Practice: Steel Man This Position

Your Turn to Steel Man

Here's a poorly presented argument. Try to steel man it:

Original Weak Argument: "I hate social media. It's just a waste of time and makes everyone stupid and narcissistic. We should all just delete our accounts."